Nobody Wants a Valuation - You Need a Valuation to Get What You Want
- May 6
- 5 min read
Updated: May 8
Learn how valuation quality often shapes the outcome quality.
As The Rolling Stones famously observed, “You cannot always get what you want. But if you try sometimes, you get what you need.”
That idea captures an important truth about valuation.
Nobody wakes up wanting a valuation. Business owners want liquidity. Families want to transfer wealth. Partners want resolution. Donors want impact. Litigants want closure.
The valuation is rarely the objective. It is a requirement that makes the objective possible.
In private markets, outcomes do not happen because they are desired. Valuation provides the economic proof that allows transactions, transfers, settlements, deductions, and strategies to move forward with credibility.
Strip away the technical language, and a simple pattern emerges:
Want → Requirement → Need
Once recognized, the pattern appears everywhere.
Want: Money
Requirement: Audit
Need: Valuation
A founder seeks capital to expand operations. The story is compelling, the growth is real, the opportunity is clear. But capital providers do not fund stories alone. They require verification, credible financials, defensible assumptions, and a clear understanding of risk and return. That is where valuation enters. It translates narrative into economics. It answers the question behind every investment decision: What is this worth, and why? An audit may validate the numbers, but a valuation gives those numbers meaning. Without it, the conversation stalls. With it, the deal becomes actionable.
Takeaway: Money follows valuation credibility.
Want: Transfer or gift stock or options
Requirement: Tax reporting
Need: Valuation
A business owner transfers shares to a trust for children ahead of a potential liquidity event.
The intent is clear: move value efficiently and thoughtfully.
Tax authorities, however, require more than intent.
• What was transferred?
• At what value?
• Under what assumptions?
A valuation provides that answer. It establishes a defensible baseline that can withstand scrutiny. Without it, the transfer is exposed and subject to challenge, penalties, and retroactive adjustment. With it, the strategy holds.
Takeaway: Wealth transfers succeed when value is supportable.
Want: Charitable contribution
Requirement: Tax deduction
Need: Valuation
A donor contributes privately held stock to a charitable organization instead of cash.
The impact is meaningful, and the tax deduction is expected. Yet deductions for non-cash contributions require a qualified appraisal. The tax benefit depends entirely on the ability to substantiate value. A weak or unsupported valuation can result in the deduction being reduced or denied altogether. A rigorous valuation preserves both the donor’s intent and the expected benefit.
Takeaway: Generosity alone does not create a deduction. Proof does.
Want: Shareholder buyout
Requirement: Agreement or judicial determination
Need: Valuation
Two partners who built a company over decades decide to part ways.
• One wants out.
• The other wants continuity.
• Both want fairness.
• The challenge is price.
Buy-sell agreements often point to a valuation process, but even then, interpretation and assumptions vary. If the agreement fails, courts step in (and courts rely heavily on valuation). It is important to recognize that valuation does not eliminate disagreement. It defines the battlefield. Different standards of value, different assumptions about growth or risk, and different incentives can produce different conclusions. The role of valuation is not to remove tension, but to structure it.
Takeaway: In conflict, valuation turns opinion into argument, and argument into resolution.
Want: Litigation resolution
Requirement: Agreement or judicial determination
Need: Valuation
A commercial dispute alleges economic harm, lost profits, diminished value, or an unfair transaction. Each side tells a different story. Resolution requires more than competing narratives. It requires quantification. A valuation converts claims into numbers. Valuation anchors negotiation and informs judgment.
• Without valuation, disputes remain abstract and prolonged.
• With valuation, disputes become measurable and, ultimately, resolvable.
Takeaway: Courts do not resolve stories. Courts resolve numbers.
Want: Divorce resolution
Requirement: Agreement or judicial determination
Need: Valuation
A privately held business included in a marital estate. Neither party necessarily wants to dissect its value, but both need clarity to move forward. A valuation provides a framework for equitable distribution. It turns a complex, illiquid asset into a quantifiable figure that can be divided, offset, or negotiated. As in other contexts, assumptions matter. Small differences in methodology can lead to materially different outcomes. That is why credible, well-supported valuation work is essential.
Takeaway: Resolution requires translation. Valuation translates complexity into clarity.
Want: IRS audit resolution
Requirement: Agreement or judicial determination
Need: Valuation
A prior transaction is under IRS audit.
• The taxpayer wants closure.
• The IRS wants accuracy.
The question becomes whether the original value reported was reasonable. A valuation, either contemporaneous or retrospective, becomes central evidence. A valuation can support the original position or establish a revised position that leads to settlement. Without a defensible valuation, the taxpayer is negotiating from a position of weakness.
Takeaway: In an IRS audit, valuation is not paperwork. Valuation is defense.
The Cost of Getting It Wrong
It is tempting to treat valuation as a compliance exercise, to minimize cost, move quickly, and “check the box.” That approach carries real risk:
• Tax deductions can be disallowed.
• Transfers can be recharacterized.
• Deals can collapse under scrutiny.
• Disputes can drag on, increasing legal cost.
• Courts can impose outcomes based on opposing experts.
In each case, the underlying issue is the same: The valuation did not hold up. A valuation is not valuable because it exists. It is valuable because it is credible.
A Necessary Tension
There is another truth worth acknowledging: valuations are not neutral. They are built on assumptions about growth, risk, markets, and behavior.
• Reasonable professionals can disagree.
• Incentives differ.
• Context matters.
This does not weaken the role of valuation. It reinforces it. Because when outcomes matter, the quality of those assumptions, and the discipline behind them, becomes decisive.
A Reframing Worth Adopting
Valuation is not a burden imposed at the end of a process. Valuation is a strategic tool that shapes outcomes from the beginning. A well-executed valuation:
• Clarifies expectations.
• Aligns stakeholders.
• Strengthens negotiating positions.
• Reduces uncertainty.
• Protects against future challenges.
In some cases, the most valuable outcome of a valuation is discovering that what is wanted is not achievable under current assumptions. That insight, early, is far less costly than disappointment later.
You just might find You get what you need
Nobody wants a valuation. Everyone wants what a valuation makes possible. You do not get the outcome because you want it. You get it because you can support it.
If the outcome matters, the valuation is not optional, it is leverage.
Adams Capital offers a no-cost initial consultation for business owners navigating these challenging times. Let us help assess where you stand and how to protect and grow the value of your business.
Please email us at anthony@adamscapital.com or call us directly at 770.432.0308 to schedule a consultation or to learn more.
Author
David Adams is the President of Adams Capital, LLC. He is an expert in the valuation of businesses, business interests, and tangible and intangible property for mergers and acquisitions, corporate recapitalization, privatization, gift and estate tax planning, bankruptcy proceedings, dissenting shareholders, Employee Stock Ownership Plans, and financial and tax reporting. Frequently counseling business owners and families on methodologies to enhance shareholder value.
Comments